What is Cultural Studies?
Main Concerns and History
Basic introd.
Further
Discussion
Hegemony theory in cultural studies operates not always quite as formated by Gramsci. The concept has been expanded and elaborated to take into account other areas of struggle. Whereas for Gramsci the concept is used to explain and explore relations of power articulated in terms of class, recent formulations in cultural studies have extended the concept to include, for example, gender, race, meaning and pleasure. (1: 10) history
Neo-Gramscian hegemony theory at its best insists that there is a dialectic between the processes of production and the activities of consumption. The consumer always confronts a text or practice in its material existence as a result of determinate conditions of production. But in the same way, the text or practice is confronted by a consumer who in effect produce in use the range of possible meaning(s)--these cannot just be read off from the materiality of the text or practice, or the means or relations of its production. (1: 9)In every decade in the history of cultural studies, the point has been made and repeated. It is the 'Gramscian insistence' (before, with and after Gramsci), learnt from Marx, that we make culture and we are made by culture; that is agency and there is structure.
[Hall] argues that cultural texts are not inscribed with meaning guaranteed once and for all by the intentions of production; meaning is always the result of an act of 'articulation' meaning meaning has to be expressed, but it is always expressed in a specific context, a specific historical moment, within a specific discourse(s). Thus expression is always connected (articulated) to and conditioned by context. (1:4)
50's
社會主義者的人道主義(socialist humanism) |
Hoggart, Williams, Thompson; 新左派 | 創造力行動主體 |
60's --
culturalist |
||
70's 初 --structuralistma
結構馬克斯主義 |
Althusser 的反人道主義 | 反對將主體及其生活經驗視為歷史的來源 |
70中期--
Gramsci vs. -- Derrida +論述理論 -- Althusser + Lacan |
爭論點:1。文化形式、經驗及階級位置的對應關係;2。可能的抗拒位置與抗拒形式 | |
80's 中期 -- postmodern debate |
Guiding
principles of hegemony
Cultural
Studies and Marxism