Postmodern Poetry
"Superior Lake" by Lorine Niedecker
as an Example
-
Conte, Joseph M. Unending Design: the
Form of Postmodern Poetry. Introduction.
-
McCorkle, James. ¡§The Inscription
of Postmodernism in Poetry.¡¨
Taiwanese Postmodern Poetry (an
Outline in Chinese)
Louise Chen, 11/26/1998
Postmodern poetics respond to the condition
of the world. In an age of instant telecommunications and metropolitan
life, the postmodern serial and procedural forms attempt to accommodate
the overwhelming diversity of messages and the lapse of a grand order that
is replaced by an arbitrary personal order.
I. Language
A. In postmodern poetics, there is
a paradigmatic shift from the idea that language is
transparent to the disclosure of its physicality,
its intimacy, its obdurate persistence, and its
paradoxical fragility. (M 43)
B. Reader¡Xpoem:
The reader's position is contingent upon
the poem and the poem¡¦s existence hinges upon
the reader and the varieties of knowledge
the reader brings to the poem¡KThe adequation of
thing and sign has lapsed with the realization
of the arbitrary condition of language. (M 43)
II. Self
A. Contemporary poetry:
1. Contemporary poetry positions its perspectives
from a persona (who is often autobiographic) within a defined narrative
structure.
2. Contemporary poetry avoids self-criticism
and establishes itself as a singled unified voice. (M 48)
B. Postmodern poetry:
1. Postmodernist poetics suggests an
ongoing reinterpretation of the self in the context of others. It specifically
investigates the ethical-or self-critical capacity of language and its
relationship to identity. (M 46)
2. The critique of the privileged and entitled
¡§I¡¨ is central to postmodern poetics. While not
a wholesale endorsement of many theoretic claims to he death of the author
or the abandonment of intention, postmodern poetry nonetheless insists
on a re-visioning of the authorial voice and its reception. (M 46)
III. Modernism
-
The central tenet of modernism, as propounded
by Clement Greenberg, is that no text
exists outside and beyond itself. (M 44)
B. There is a ¡§desire for organization
coherence, a focus of locale, a central narrative persona,
and unifying themes are present.(M 48)
C. In modern works, there is the interruption
of poems by pose arrangements, but the
modernism prose fragments imply a cultural
community or artifacts constituting a whole.
(M 48)
IV. Postmodernism
A. Postmodern world
-
It presents a technological person divorced
from an environment that he gamely attempts
to "manage" or "condition." Postmodern
form responds to the conditions of the modern
world. (C 16)
-
Postmodern world is aware of what has generally
been perceived as the lapse of
governing orders in our existence. The
postmodern artist has little confidence in
suprahuman orders, and she will readily
concede that whatever order may be apparent in
the world is largely a projection of the
human mind. (C 17)
-
The universe is ineffable. We are that much
more inclined to disbelieve the fictions of its coherence. (C 17)
B. Art and society
1. Working through such modes as appropriation,
synthesis, recombination, mutation and
generation, postmodern poetics expresses
a commitment to the dialogical, social world.
(M 44)
2. Postmodern art constitutes a significant
and deliberate break with the "spatial form" of
modernism in its paradoxical use of self-conscious
art, not to separate itself from, but to refer to and engage the dominant
discourse of hegemony. (M 44)
3. The abandonment by science of a unidirectional
system of causation for a multidirectional field of possibilities encourages
a corresponding shift in the arts from closed to open forms. (C 19)
C. Postmodern poetics
-
Despite its frequent recourse to a renewed
formalism, postmodern poetry rejects the notion of an autonomous poem,
self, or culture; while truth or identity can not be anchored, the poem
offers through its very inception the possibility of transformation. (M
43).
2. In postmodern poetry the intrusion of prose
signals the awareness of the arbitrariness of form and language. It is
a form that seeks to obstruct the received representation of the poem or
the idea of the poem per se. (M 48)
3. Artifice is¡Kthe recognition that
a poem or painting or performance text is a made
thing¡Xcontrived, constructed, chosen¡Xand
that its reading is also a construction on the
part of its audience. (M 45)
V. General concepts of serial
and procedural forms
A. Serial form
-
Poets such as Creeley, Opeen, and Spicer have
discerned a serial order that is ¡§protean¡¨
and provisional. It incorporates random
occurrences without succumbing to
formlessness. (C 11)
-
In a ¡§protean¡¨ order
the poet as Menelaus struggles to capture the incessantly changing,
fluid, and contiguous phenomena as
they occur. (C 11)
-
Poets tend to make ¡§a quick graph¡¨
of the acknowledged disorder as it occurs. Seriality
is a somewhat desultory topological
map of the ¡§ground¡¨ of existence. (C 17)
-
Serial works are characterized by the discontinuity
of their elements and the centrifugal
force identified with an ¡§open¡¨
aesthetic. (C 42)
B. Procedural form
-
Poets such as Ashbery, Mathews, and Cage have
entertained a procedural order that is
¡§proteinic¡¨
and predetermined. It employs arbitrary constrains to generate the content
of
the poem instead of merely containing it,
as in traditional fixed forms.
-
In a ¡§proteinic¡¨ order
the poet initiates an encoded structure or network that builds on
itself, replicates with variation,
and produces the text. (C11-12)
-
Poets enlist an admittedly arbitrary and personal
order as mediation between the mind
and its environs. Proceduralism produces
a grid transparently superimposed on¡Xand as
easily lifted from¡Xexistence. (C
17)
-
Procedural works are typified by the recurrence
of elements and a centripetal force that
promises a self-sustaining momentum.
(C 42)
VI. Serial
form
-
Prototype¡XWilliam Carlos Williams¡¦
Spring
and All (1923)¡Xconsists of twenty-seven
numbered, untitled poems interspersed with
prose arguments. Williams¡¦s demand in one
argument that poetry be ¡§new
form dealt with as a reality in itself.¡¨ ¡Kthe series
distinguishes itself from the neoromantic
sequence principally because it forgoes the
linear, thematic development of that form¡K
Williams¡¦s book can be considered the
prototype for those poems whose form is
both discontinuous and capable of recombination.
(C 20)
B. General characteristics
1.The open form of the poetic series is
defined by its limitless set of relations; it takes its
shape from the diverse ways in which
items come together.(C 15)
2. The series are the product of ¡§a
¡¥stemmatous¡¦ imagination of the chain or network.¡¨
They function as ¡§an arrangement
of mobile, substitutive parts, whose combination
produces meaning, or more generally a new
object.¡¨ The serial form is thus based on the
complex and multifarious means by which
, as Rovert Creeley points out, one thing finds
its place with another. (C 21)
3. The serial form in poetry is one of
¡§those works,¡¨ as Barthes puts it, ¡§whose
fabrication,
by arrangement of discontinuous and mobile
elements-or their resistance to a
determinate order. (C 21)
-
The series does not aspire to the encompassment
of the epic; nor does it allow for the
reduction of its materials to the isolated
perfection of the single lyric. The series
demands neither summation nor exclusion.
It is instead a combinative form whose
arrangements admit a variegated set of
materials. (C 21)
-
The series is an open form in large part because
it does not require the ¡§mechanic¡¨
imposition of an external organization.
It is not, however, an ¡§organic¡¨ form. (C 22)
-
In a series the reader is encouraged to select
any of these ¡§passages¡¨ as an entrance.
(C 23)
8. The postmodern theorist proposes an open
structure that welcomes possibility, choice,
and chance. (C 24)
Sequence |
Series |
humanism |
post-humanism |
a hierarchical
cosmos |
an expanding universe |
centripetal force |
centrifugal force |
symbolic depth |
syntagmatic link |
organic |
atomistic |
unity |
recombination |
immanent |
aleatory |
linear |
curvilinear and
disjunctive |
logical |
irrational |
continuity |
discontinuity |
progression |
disruption |
a single voice |
cacophony or no
voice |
hypotactic:
arranged one
under another |
paratactic:
arranged side by
side |
metaphoric |
metonymic |
VII. Procedural
form
-
The ability of procedural forms to sustain
their own momentum derives from their relationship to the "paradigmatic
consciousness." ¡K It sees the sign in its "profile" and thus pays
particular attention to the formal relations of signs and to the regular
constraints of a work. It is attention to the system. (C 41) One
is caught, forced to move in the direction that the form dictates. (C 42)
-
A procedural form is "closed" by virtue of
its entirely predetermined structure. It is not dictated by tradition,
but assembled as a set of choices that can be disassembled or reconstituted
according to the poet¡¦s assessment of their effectiveness.
Form is not "endowed" by some suprahuman or historical authority, but "fabricated"
with an emphasis on displaying the poet's artifice. It asserts the very
arbitrary system of organization ¡K It claims the devolution of intellectual
authority to personal decision. (C15)
-
The procedural form is a generative structure
that constrains the poet to encounter and examine that which he or she
does not immediately fathom, the uncertainties and incomprehensibilities
of an expanding universe in which there can be no singular impositions.
(C16)
VIII. Lorine Niedecker's finite serial
form: "Lake Superior"
-
Objectivism
-
The Objectivist poetics pays an acute attention
to particulars and details¡Xthe hard, clear
image. The poets think with things, not
about them.
-
Cyclical form
-
"Lake Superior" is a series whose individual
poem deserves a certain degree of autonomy. They are not to be stacked
on top of one another as if they are stanzas of a single continuous poem.
Niedecker seeks to express not a single chain of cause and effect but an
"awareness of everything influencing everything" by stressing the autonomy
of the poems which form a cyclical structure.
-
Every living thing once was stone, and the
living will turn to stone again. On this cycle of the organic and inorganic,
minerals and stone are the recurrent figures in the series, as they are
in nature. Within the cycle of stone-leaf-stone, the recurrent thing does
not extinguish itself or encounter a full stop, but returns in a new and
separate environment.
-
Niedecker had eliminated the Roman numberals
which order the poems in the original arrangement. Her spare use of punctuation
throughout the series also reinforces this concept of an endless cycle:
there are no full stops, no periods.
Questions:
-
Does postmodern poetics break completely from
modern and the Coleridgean theory of organic form?
-
How does postmodern poetics correspond with
theory of postmodern fiction?