Introduction
to Literature, Spring 1999
Ray's
Syllabus
Kate's
Syllabus
Death
of a Salesman
Act
One
1. The first stage direction
is long and significant. What does it tell us about a) the characters
Willy and Linda, b) the central theme of the play (e.g. "the fragile-seeming
house," apartment buildings, the "one-dimensional" roof, the colors, the
flute, etc.)?
2. In the first dialogue between Linda
and Willy, what do we find out about
-
Willy's present conditions; What is Willy like in the "present" of the
play? Why does he always talk to himself? What is the significance
of the rubber pipe (1067; 1072)?
-
the relationship between Willy and Linda,
-
and Willy's views of Biff?
3. In the ensuing dialogue between Biff
and Happy, the two brothers are set in contrast in terms of
their working experience, their desire and dream, and their relationship
to their parents. How are they similar to each other in terms
of the ways they use to achieve their respective dream?
3. Willy and his sons in the past:
Act I shows how Willy goes back to his "glorious" past and then to a source
of his failure and sense of guilt--that is, the way he teaches his kid,
his unsuccessful business, and the affair he has with a woman. So
far you won't know why the three are interrelated, but pay attention to
each: how and why Willy does each thing, and how he tries to justify himself.
-
Willy as a salesman: What do we know about his work, in the past
and in the present? How did Willy talk about it to his sons
in the past? What was his dream? Even in the past, when he
has the red Chevvy he is proud of, does he earn a lot? Is he as "well
liked" as he says he is? (pp. 1052-54)
-
Willy and the boys: In the dialogue Willy had in the past with his
sons, what did he care most about? How does he respond to Biff's
stealing the football? Look for the signs of affection Willy and
Biff show to each other (e.g. the gift, Biff's missing him, the gesture
at touchdown).
-
Willy in the consumer society: Why is he so proud of his red Chevvy,
and Biff's "simonizing job"? How about the fridge? Why does
he and his wife believe that it is a good one when it is broken so soon?
-
Minor characters, Bernard and Charley: How do the Lomans treat them?
-
The woman with laughters: Why does the laughter emerge when
1) Willy admits his own failure, and 2) Willy heard about Biff's failures?
5. Ben and their childhood:
-
Why is Ben important to Willy?
Why does he talk about the jungle, Africa and Alaska? How is this
related to the American Dream? Why does he appear in front of Willy
while Charley is there?
How are the two a contrast to each other? What is his jungle theory
of success?
-
In his dialogue with Ben, Willy's childhood and his father are mentioned.
What kind of person is their father? Does Willy's father influence
Willy a lot? Can we see Ben as a substitute father for Willy?
6. Linda, Biff and Happy--and Willy:
-
A lot more is revealed about Willy and Linda
in the way she talks to her sons about him. Is Linda a blind admirer
of Willy? Linda's speech changes Biff's attitude toward his father.
Does she manage to win your sympathy, too? ("Attention, attention
must be finally paid to such a person"; her revelation of Willy's not earning
anything and suicidal attempts [the rubber pipe]). In other words,
do you think that Linda should be so supportive of Willy, or should she
change him?
-
Why does Biff decide to join the business world? What does Happy
say about Biff in his business world? Why is "whistling in the evelator"
important?
7. The end of Act I shows that the father and the sons have their new plans.
Are they feasible ones? Why do they think they can selling sporting
goods? How does Willy respond to the sons' plan? What do you
think about the way he tries to teach Biff (the business suit, no joke,
no Gee, no modesty; personality wins the day)? Do you think
that he ever changes over these twenty years about his ways of treating
Biff?
Act
Two
The end of Act One shows the two strands of plot--one about the past
and one about the father and the sons' future plans--coming together, with
the father and the sons trying to make up for the past conflict through
working on their future plans.
A. the present
conditions
1. The consumer society, installment
and insurance -- At the beginning of this act, we see Linda
and Willy talk about the household electric wares such as the fridge, which
is similar to the one they had in the "past" of Act I. What is ironic
about Willy's complaints about the Hastings refrigerator and the installment
plan? And "to weather a twenty-five year mortgage" as an accomplishment?
2. Garden and fine tools -- Besides
being pre-occupied with the past and trying to improve his job and relationship
with Biff, another thing dominates Willy's thinking is his desire to have
a garden and plant vegetables in "a little place out in the country" and
then in his backyard. Is the country, then, set as a contrast to
the city in this play? What does this reveal about Willy's personality?
Does planting help him keep his sense of identity in a big and alienating
city?
B. efforts to
carry out the future plans
1. The future plans get denied in Act II. How? What causes
Willy's and Biff's failures, their personality, or the competitive business
world?
2. The business world -- When
Willy talks to Howard, several things shows the real nature of this business
world (which is a contrast to Willy's emphasis on adventurousness, personality
and personal contacts).
-
wire recorder -- Besides Howard's attempt to catch up with the newest trend
in the world of machanical reproduction, what else is this machine symbolic
of? Pay close attention to what he records (the daughter's whistling,
the son's reading the names of the capitals and the wife's inability to
speak) and how Willy is incompetent in front of this machine.
-
What is Howard's attitude toward Willy's plea to stay in New York?
Does he care about the history Willy recounts?
-
How does Willy try to compromise?
3. Biff at Oliver's office --
-
What's the difference between being a salesman and a "shipping clerk"?
Why does Biff realize that he, like his father and brother, has been talking
in a dream? What does he realize after his experience at the
office?
-
Why does Biff take the fountain pen away from Oliver?
 |
4. Willy vs. Charley, Biff vs. Bernard
-- At Charley's office, we get to see both Charley and Bernard
quite successful, a contrast to Willy and Biff. What make the two
pairs of father and son different from each other? Consider
some of the comments Charley and Barnard make: |
-
Bernard[about Biff] "He never train himself for anything."
-
Charley: "My salvation is that I never took interest
in anything."
-
Charley: "Why must everybody like you? Who liked
J.P. Morgan? . . . In a Turkish bath he'd look like a butcher.
But with his pockets on him he was very well liked."
5. Happy --
To follow up on the contrast that has been set in Act I, here we get
to see more of Happy as a womanizer. What gets to be revealed more
is his attitudes toward his father.
-
What does Happy ask Biff to say to Willy instead of admitting his
failure?
-
When Happy denies that Willy is their father, is it surprising? Are
there other clues to prepare for this (e.g. how much money does he give
to his parents while staying with them)?
C. the past --About
the past, there seems to be one event that both Biff and Willy are preoccupied
with but stay away from; one event that is the major cause of the conflict
between the father and the son. (Clues: The way Biff puts it is,
"Because I know he's a fake and he doesn't like anybody around who knows!"
Biff's response when Linda says "There was a woman," and Bernard's question
of Willy.) It is when both the father's and the son's future plans
are denied that Willy is pushed gradually to the past as both an escape
and the source of his sense of guilt. His conversation with Howard
marks his first return to the past in Act II.
 |
1). How is the past revelation developed? Pay close attention
to the juxtaposition of the past and the present and their interrelationship.
How does Willy try to get away with his sense of failure twice in this
Act when talking to Howard and then to Biff? |
 |
Like in Act I, here he still looks for self-justification in Ben and
then in the football game episode (the climax of happiness and success
in the past). Bernard's question, however, forces him to face the
Boston hotel scene -- the beginning of his bad relationship with Biff and
Biff's downfall. Then the event finally emerges in Willy's mind when
Biff reveals his present failure and after Biff and Happy left him at the
bar.
2) After he is fired by Howard, the first hallucination is
about his talk with Ben, and then we have the scene of the family's going
to Ebbets Field to watch Biff play in a football game. How do the
two scenes function for Willy? As an escape? A self-justification?
3) In the bar, how does Willy refuse to listen to Biff's actual experience
with Bill Oliver? At the point when Biff said, "I can't talk to him,"
there is the intrusion of Bernard from the past ("Mrs. Loman, Mrs. Loman!").
How does Willy try to escape from both the present and the past?
(Clues: he says, "I'm not in my room!") Ironically, as Willy goes
to the restroom, he is confronted with the past he tries hard to forget.
4) How does Willy walk out of this emotional encounter with the past?
At the moment, he is actually left behind by his beloved sons, but he remembers
to pay Stanley and then he goes off to buy and plant the seeds. What
do you think about this behavior?
3. The father and the sons and the reconcilation
--
-
In the final argument and reconciliation between Biff and Willy, what is
revealed by Biff?
Why does Willy commit suicide at the end? (Clues: the end of his
conversation with Charley; with Ben, and his final argument and reconciliation
with Biff 1106-1111). What does "the jungle is dark but full of diamonds"
mean?
The
Requiem & the Play as a whole
(Here
a lot of Arthur Miller's interpretations are quoted, and you will find
that MIller tries hard to persuade us that Willy Loman is a tragic hero.
However, you do not need to agree with the author.)
1. Is Willy
Loman a tragic hero who acts and wins our esteem? Or is he a victim?
A victim of his own character or of a system of ruthless competition?
A. Personality --
-
Willy Loman, for Miller as he pointed out in a 1958 symposium, "is seeking
for a kind of ecstasy in life, which the machine-civilization deprives
people of. He's looking for his selfhood, for his immortal soul,
so to speak." Miller thinks that Willy's problem is in having values
that cannot be realized. Do you agree? What are Willy
Loman's dreams, for himself, for his family, and especially for Biff?
Why does he, or his sons, fail to realize them?
-
The mature Bernard says to Willy: "it's better for a man just to walk away."
Why cannot Willy? Do you see his persistence a flaw or a merit?
-
What could he and his family have done to avoid the tragedy?
B. The circumstances (1) -- Willy's family
background
-
What is Willy searching for? Who, or what, instills in Willy his
dream for something glorious? Could it be that he is actually searching
for his father, for feeling secure and not "temporary"? With his
sons, is Willy a good father? Has he been wanting to be a good father?
C. The circumstances (2) --
American Capitalist/Industrial society and the American Dream
-
Why does Willy want to both earn more money and go out in the country or
to the West? Are there contradictions in his dream?
-
Consider the roles of what Miller calls "the machine-civilization" in the
novel: the car, the vacuum clean, the fridge the installment system and
the wire recorder. Is Willy a victim of this system?
-
In several passages Linda talks about Willy's loneliness, his not being
known and not being appreciated. How is that related to contemporary
caplitalist society?
-
For Miller, there is a law that governs Willy's society (and maybe ours):
the law of success, "a law which says that a faillure in society and
in business has no right to live" (169), and Willy has broken that law.
This reminds us of Linda's plea for attention and respect for Willy.
We can, however, put the issue differently: is "successful or not" our
standard of judging and evaluating people? Or one's ways of dealing
with one's own success and failure? How does Willy deal with his
failures? How does he "succeed"?
D. Ending -- For Arthur Miller,
a tragic hero is one "who is ready to lay down his life, if need be, to
secure one thing--his
sense of personal dignity" ("Arthur Miller, on Tragedy
and the Common Man"). Why does Willy commit suicide at the end?
Does he, as a result, gain his personal dignity?
Consider the characters' comments on Willy:
-
[End of Act I] Linda:
" I don't say he's a great man. Willy Loman never made a lot of money.
His name was never in the paper. He's
not the finest character
that ever lived. But he's a human being, and a terrible thing is happening
to him. So attention must be paid. He's not to be allowed to fall into
his grave like an old dog. Attention, attention must be finally paid to
such a person. "
-
[The bar scene in Act II] Biff:
"A fine, troubled prince. A hardworking, unappreciated prince. A pal, you
understand? A good companion. Always for his boys.
-
[Requiem] Charley:
Nobody dast blame this man. You don't understand: Willy was a salesman.
And for a salesman, there is no rock bottom to the life. He don't put a
bolt to a nut, he don't tell you the law or give you medicine. He's a man
way out there in the blue, riding on a smile and a shoeshine. and when
they start not smiling back -- that's an earthquake. . ."
Biff: Charley,
the man didn't know who he was.
Happy: Don't
say that!
2. Linda's roles:
-
In the first stage direction, Miller describes Linda as one who "admires"
Willy, who shares his longings "but lacks the temperament to utter and
follow to their end" (1039). Is Linda, then, a blind follower of
Willy, and a submissive and quiet care-taker of the family? What
other roles does she play ? Consider her speech with her sons.
What does it mean when she said she at the end that "[she] can't cry.
[She doesn't] understand it [why Willy commit suicide]"?.What does it mean
when she then says, "We're free and clear...We're free..."?
-
Describe Linda's importance to Willy and esp. to Biff. In a sense,
when Biff tries to "make good," he does it more for Linda than for Willy.
Why? Out of his Oedipal love for Linda or as an attempt for make
up for her?
3. Compare Biff and Happy.
-
Why does Biff fail to meet Willy's expectation? Do you find
his final comment on himself and his father courageous self-realization
or cowardly self-rejection?
-
The ending shows that Happy wants to realize Willy's dream of becoming
a "number-one man." Do you think he will make it? Does Biff
know more about what American dream is? When Happy says that "I'm
gonna show you and everybody else that Willy Loman did not die in vain.
He had a good dream. It's the only dream you can have -- to come out
number-one man. He fought it out here, and this is where I'm gonna win
it for him," does he show his true love for Willy or his fascination with
the dream?
4. Expressionist techinques:
Miller once said that "Any dramatic form is an artifice, a way of transforming
a subjective feeling into something that can be comprehended through
public symbols." (Introduction to Collected Plays from the Viking
version p. 156)
-
Discuss the significance of the flute: what it represents and why, and
the moments when its music is heard. (e.g. 1039; 1048; 1060-61; 1113)
-
Symbolic expressions: Here is
a list of things with symbolic meanings in the text (listed by David
Biele in his Teacher's
Guide.) Please look for them in the text and find out their significance
and symbolic meanings.
Home |
Road/Places
|
Signs o/ temporal
changes
|
Commodities |
Success/Failure
|
Homes/houses [e.g. the first
stage direction; the mortgage]
Seeds/plants/trees
[e.g. Willy's first dialgue
with Linda about their environment, Willy last attempt to buy seeds]
Walls/buildings
Air
Working with tools/one's hands[e.g.
Willy's argument with Charley towards the end of Act I: :A man who can't
handle tools is not a man." "hammer a nail"]
|
Roads -- [be
on the road]
References to the country
Cars/boats/trains: [e.g.
Willy's Red Chevvy; Willy compared to "alittle boat looking for a harbor"
by Linda; Ben's taking the train.]
|
Watches/clocks & references
to time
flute [Willy's father]
other kinds of music--e.g. jarring
trumpet note, Willy's theme, Ben's theme
[the end of Act II; ]
light of green leaves
|
Linda's stockings
[e.g. towards the end of
Act I, when the woman appears]
Things {Fridge, car] that are
broken/falling apart
vacuum cleaner
wire recorder
|
References to growing up/becoming
a man or adult
References to far away places
[e.g. the West, Alaska, Africa] and gold, diamonds
References to building things
[e.g. what Willy does to his house--as Biff describes it in the Requiem]
References to succeeding/failing
Seeing Biff as Adonis, Hercules
References to winning/losing
|
-
The past and the present: The
play shifts a lot between the past and the present, which shows that the
characters are preoccupied with the past. What is the central event
in the past that both Willy and Biff are preoccupied with? How is
the past juxtaposed with the present, as a parallel, a contrast, or a cause?
Consider, again, Miller's comment: "There are no flashbacks in this play
but only a mobile concurrency of past and present.. . . "(Introduction
to Collected Plays from the Viking version p. 159-60)
-
The Stage Directions:
1) The stage directions, first of all, switch to the past scene
and then back to the present, as the filim fades in and out of the major
present and past scenes (i.e. present dining room, the past backyard, the
present bar and the past Boston hotel room). Pay attention
to the things the stage directions mention to make the transition (e.g.
the woman's laughter, Bernard's words, the flute, etc.) Why?
If we see the whole play as dominated by Willy's stream of consciousness
(the original title of the play is Inside his Head), what important
do these words and gestures and object have in his mind?
-
Read closely and you will find how the stage performance on is different
from the film version. Besides the merging/ the film shows Willy
going to places. But how about the play?
For
your reference: Background
The
Author
Miller's Inspirations for Salesman
"Death of a Salesman
began as a short story that Arthur Miller wrote at the age of seventeen
while he was working for his father's company. . . . "
"In his autobiography Timebends, . . . Miller based
Willy Loman largely on his own uncle, Manny Newman. . . .
Miller described Newman as a man who was 'a competitor at all
times, in all things, and at every, moment.' Miller said that his
uncle saw "my brother and I running neck and neck with his two
sons [Buddy and Abby] in some horse race [for success] that never
stopped in his mind." He also said that the Newman household was
one in which you 'dared not lose hope, and I would later think of
it as a perfection of America for that reason...It was a house trembling
with resolution and shouts of victories that had not yet taken place but
surely would tomorrow.' The Loman home was built on the foundation
of this household. (from Student
Guide Written and Designed by David Biele)
Relevant
Links
-
Arthur Miller Bio
(playwright,
born October 17, 1915, New York, New York)
-
CHRONOLOGY
-
Concordance
to Miller, Death of a Salesman
Concordance to the complete text; includes: Complete alphabetical word
list from Death of a Salesman, complete word list by frequency from
Death of a Salesman, search for word from text of play, search for
short text section or character name, search for source location of text
in play.
-
Death
of a Salesman - Broadway production of Death of a Salesman starring
Brian Dennehy. The site has bios, reviews, and tickets for sale.
quite useful!
-
Death of a Salesman: STUDY RESOURCE CENTER
very
useful. With study guides for both teachers and students and some
related articles.
-
More study guides: 1. Student's
Study Guide; 2. Teacher
Guide; 3. Penguin
Reading and Responding Guide
-
Death
of a Salesman Review
-
Death
of a Salesman Links
-
Death
of a Salesman - Death of a Salesman American Drama 1996 Issue
and links for Miller Aristotle's Definition of Tragedy and Modern Drama
Review of Play Return to Junior Honors page
-
Death
of a Salesman - Death of a Salesman By Arthur Miller Directed
by Jim Moc
-
Death
of a Salesman (Summary Page)
-
Death
of a Salesman - The following essays were written by Ms. Susan
Collura's Sophomore Honors class at Holy Cross High School, Flushing, New
York
-
Vocabulary from Death
of a Salesman by XXX for VOCAB U. - Our mission is to
"make words come alive"
in a dynamic, new approach to learning vocabulary featured here at Vocabulary
University on the WWWeb.
-
A
General Introduction