Balibar, Etienne. "The Nation Form"¡ÐReview XIII
3 (Summer 1990): 329-61.
purpose: to clarify...that of the causes and "deep" structures of contemporary
racism.
-
I´º Terminology: nation and state; social formation;
world state-system;
Marxist historiography: functionalist (nation as instrument of bourgeois
hegemony) and historicist (nation overdetermining class struggle)
¡ö¡÷study national unity as an
historical reality in fact divided because of antagonistic class strategies,
or even as the long-term consequence of a continuous transformation of
"class" identities and the unstable equilibria established between
opposing interests
Althusser's influence: ISA as combined functioning of several dominant
institutions (102)
-
ºKn
-
History:
-
Pre-history¡Ðon-linear, a series of conjunctural relations (e.g.
institution of national language, development of monarchical power, centralization
of legal and fiscal power, the complementariness of church and state )
-
threshhold¡Ðnation and world economy¡Ðthe concurrence
of nationalism and cosmopolitanism
-
(delayed) nationlization of society¡Ðstate bourgeoisie?
-
producing the people--institution of individuals as nationals¡Ð
methods: education, force, analogy of religion, fictive ethnicity
(every identity is individual, but socially produced) (only imaginary
communities are real)
--unification of people by ideological form, e.g. patriotism, nationalism
-
fictive ethnicity and ideal nation¡Ðnaturalization of belonging
-
the production of ethnicity through language and race¡Ðracialization
of language, verbalization of race
-
family and school¡Ðthe dissolution of extended family// penetrated
by state-intervention (e.g. health care, census, birth control, eugenics)
issues:
-
language community (98)The linguistic community induces
a terribly constraining ethnic memory…, but it is one which none the less
possess a strange plasticity: it immediately naturalizes new acquisitions.
It does so too quickly in a sense....Ideally, it 'assimilates' anyone,
but holds no one.
-
The future of nation (p. 91; 105) in globalism
-
topics for future discussion: fictive ethnicity, national history and language,
different nation forms (U.S. vs. France, US vs. Canada, Canada vs. UK,
etc.)
|